Careers

Madison Mutual Insurance Company has been around for over 100 years because it's an excellent place to work and grow professionally.  Come join us!

Agency Supervisor

Collinsville, IL
May 15, 2025
Job Summary

The Agency Supervisor will be a licensed professional insurance agent who is responsible for developing and executing long-term strategic agency plans. In addition, this role will oversee the day-to-day operations of the agency and supervise the employees on site. Working collaboratively with their team to administer marketing plans and expected sales goals and targets in a projected time frame.

Qualifications

• 5+ years of insurance agency supervisory experience

• Must hold current producers license

• Excellent written and verbal skills

• Proficient computer knowledge

• Sales and goal oriented

• Professional appearance and attitude

• Ability to solicit and sell policies from multiple carriers in an accurate and efficient manner

Essential Functions and Responsibilities

• Follow and execute marketing plans to solicit new and existing business using the output from the agency management system.

• Provide accurate quotes to customers from all carriers and convert them into accurate and complete applications after obtaining agreement to purchase.

• Close sales in a timely manner, keeping sales goals in mind.

• Ability to confidently discuss UW issues with customers and pivot customers to a different carrier or alternative coverage options when necessary.

• Update job knowledge by participating in educational opportunities.

• Accomplish sales and policy in force goals by accepting ownership for effective administering of marketing and policy retention campaigns

• Assisting the marketing department with potential ideas for new campaigns to drive new sales and improved policy retention

• Explore opportunities to add value to job accomplishments by assisting in the transformation of successful delivering of new business sales and retention targets for the agency into ideas/concepts/programs for all Madison Mutual agents as per the strategic plan.

• Providing on-site operational management of assigned agent location, including but not limited to, ensuring safety and security of all on-site employees, reporting any attendance or performance issues with on-site personnel to appropriate manager, reporting and taking appropriate actions due to any facility related issues at agent location.

Salary Range - $55,000-$65,000 annually

  • Health insurance
  • Flexible spending account
  • Health savings account
  • Dental insurance
  • Vision insurance
  • Life insurance
  • Short Term Disability
  • Long Term Disability
  • Employee assistance program
  • Employee Wellness program
  • Paid time off
  • Tuition reimbursement
  • Industry Licensing / Professional Designation Reimbursement
  • 401(k)
  • 401(k) matching